This site is no longer being updated. View a directory of Maryland blogs and daily hand-picked posts at BaltimoreSun.com/localblogs.

Should the Elgin Marbles go Back to Greece?

Posted on Sunday, January 10th, 2010 at 3:23 pm

Photo: GV

Photo: GV

This decades-old question has new urgency, thanks to the stunningly-beautiful new museum in Athens dedicated to the Acropolis. Something is missing, say the Greeks (www.culture.gr). Not so, say the English (www.britishmuseum.org).

IMG_4731

In the British Museum, so the argument goes, you can see the sculptures close up and personal, and millions upon millions have had the pleasure of becoming acquainted with one of the great architectural monuments of all time, without a trip to Athens.

Photo: GV

Photo: GV

And, after all, who knows what may have happened to these great works in those dangerous times, two centuries ago, when what is now Greece was part of the Ottoman Empire – had not Lord Elgin stepped in?

And then, in the label, a more suble thought is expressed, that in effect makes didactic allies of the old British Museum and the New Acropolis Museum.

Photo: GV

Photo: GV

If you were a Trustee of the British Museum, how would you vote?

Filed in: Architecture, Art, Cultural Property, Greece.



 

744 Responses

  1. Elmo

    After seeing so much destruction of art and cultural heritage during the looting of Baghdad, I’ve come to the conclusion that wide dispersal is a better strategy for curation than is concentration; even when the place of concentration is the “original” location.

Leave a Reply

  • About Gary Vikan

    Gary Vikan, director of the Walters Art Museum since 1994, has been with the Baltimore institution for more than 20 years. A native of Minnesota, Gary received his B.A. from Carleton College in 1967 and his Ph.D. from Princeton University in 1976 before working as Senior Associate for Byzantine Art Studies at Dumbarton Oaks in Washington, D.C.

    An internationally known medieval art scholar, Gary has curated many significant exhibitions at the Walters, and has published and lectured on the early Christian pilgrimage, medicine and magic, icons, the Shroud of Turin, neuroscience and aesthetics, and Elvis Presley. His most recent book, Early Byzantine Pilgrimage Art, will be published in 2010 by Dumbarton Oaks; he is currently working on a book-length study titled Pilgrimage to Graceland.

  • recent charm city current posts

  • Recent Comments

  • RSS walters art museum on twitter

  • categories

  • archives